Does CAPTCHA stop fraud? Kim Tan November 23, 2022
I'm not a robot, I swear!
Every time we log in or sign up for online websites, we see this question that poses an existential crisis: are you a robot? Then a series of tests ensues, reminiscent of the tests we take during kindergarten to prove our humanness online.
What is this test, and is it the standard security measure on the web we have today?
What is a CAPTCHA?
It is called the "Completely Automated Public Turing test to tell Computers and Humans Apart," or CAPTCHA for short. In other words, it's a simple challenge-response test to verify that a person is human when completing an action on your website.
Two most commonly used CAPTCHA types:
Although there are many types of CAPTCHA tests, these are the top two most used kinds that you might be familiar with:
A distorted image test
A picture with letters or numbers that humans, not machines, can read.
Picture identification test
A test of separating photographs from a collection of images and identifying an unusual image from the collection.
What does CAPTCHA do?
A CAPTCHA is a test that's supposed to tell humans from bots. Websites use CAPTCHAs to stop bots from accessing the site.
How secure is CAPTCHA?
CAPTCHAs are most commonly used to protect websites from spam bots. Still, their effectiveness has been called into question by experts such as CAPTCHA creator Luis von Ahn who have criticized the technology as outdated and unreliable at stopping fraud in recent years.
Why captchas are getting harder
The weakness of CAPTCHAs in stopping fraud.
Even the strongest CAPTCHAs are not perfect. There are ways to bypass them, and spammers and scammers aren't afraid to use them.
CAPTCHA bots are too advanced.
Today's bot operators have a wide range of tools, including manual labor methods and AI-driven solutions that can bypass a CAPTCHA. With a fast web search, these tools are easily accessible. Even non-technical people can locate a bot to get around CAPTCHAs.
How bots bypass CAPTCHAs
The most popular method for a bot to get around a CAPTCHA is to use low-cost, outsourced manual labor from a "CAPTCHA farm"
There are tools that make it simple for bot operators to interact with a company offering this service, including APIs, browser plugins, and other techniques.
Imagine what powerful, well-resourced criminal groups could accomplish if just anyone could do this.
Distorted User Experience.
CAPTCHAs not only block bots but real users too, as they distort a customer's user experience. The idea behind a CAPTCHA is that it should be difficult for computers to read and easy for humans to understand. Unfortunately, this is not always the case: CAPTCHAs can be difficult for people with disabilities to read; they can also contain too complex or small patterns for the average human eye to see clearly.
The more complex the CAPTCHA, the harder it is for bots to crack. But more complex CAPTCHAs make it difficult for humans too. It leads to mistakes that can negatively impact your business, like lost sales or abandoned registrations.
The future of CAPTCHAs.
The future of CAPTCHA is uncertain. As algorithms improve, it may become easier to crack CAPTCHAs. In the meantime, more CAPTCHAs are being replaced by alternative methods that counteract bots without requiring users to click on a series of pictures or solve another puzzle.
CAPTCHA alternatives.
Thinking about security when planning your website is definitely the way to go, but CAPTCHAs aren't always the best way to implement it. Sure, they might stop some people from breaking into your site—but they also keep legitimate users out. If you want to be sure that only humans are logging in and submitting their data, consider a mix of using other methods like the following:
Two-factor authentication
Users must enter a code generated by an app or text message in addition to their password before logging in.
Use rules to detect fraud.
This is the easiest option but is also the most basic and not always accurate. The system will scan data from certain fields and compare it to your database of good customers. If the user matches up, they'll be allowed to make an order or sign up for an account with your company.
Use machine learning to detect fraud.
This method uses algorithms that can learn from previous orders or accounts to determine whether new data should be accepted or rejected based on how similar it looks compared with past orders/accounts that were successful (or unsuccessful). Machine learning goes beyond simple rules-based systems because computers have no problem analyzing massive amounts of information quickly and efficiently—but they still aren't perfect at detecting everything out there!
The best way to stop fraud is by using many different types of anti-bot measures together. This approach reduces false positives while still detecting most bots and spam attempts. We should not hide behind the false security that CAPTCHAs give us; we must hold businesses accountable to a safer and more equitable internet environment for everyone.
Frequently asked questions on CAPTCHA stopping fraud:
What are the most common types of CAPTCHAs?
The two most common types of CAPTCHAs are distorted image tests and picture identification tests.
Are CAPTCHAs secure?
CAPTCHA is a tool to stop bots from accessing a website, but in today's time, this method of security has been outdated and unreliable at stopping fraud in recent years.
What are good CAPTCHA alternatives to stop fraud?
The best way to stop fraud is by using many different types of anti-bot measures, in conjunction with a CAPTCHA or as a total alternative. We suggest taking a look at 2-Factor authentication, machine learning, and setting up rule parameters for your site.
Are CAPTCHAs user-friendly?
CAPTCHAs are made to be distinguishable to humans, although, in recent years, CAPTCHAs are getting harder to bypass the rise of CAPTCHA bots. This, in turn, makes it harder for humans, especially those with disabilities like poor eyesight, dyslexia, etc.
In conclusion
Can CAPTCHA stop fraud? In essence, it can, although it is important to note that CAPTCHA is not a perfect solution to stop fraud – but it is still useful if used in moderation.
There are many ways to get around CAPTCHAs, and the system can be easily exploited by bots who have learned how to fill out these forms. While we would love to believe that humans are better than machines when filling out such complex tasks, this may not always be true. If you want your site or app protected from fraudsters, consider using a mix of other methods alongside CAPTCHAs!
To have a secure website and to prevent fraud, you need to strike a balance between security and usability.
About Glass.io
With Glass.io, you can reach across the screen and help visitors make a buy decision. See exactly how visitors use your website in realtime, trigger a notification to the right sales rep when they show buying intent, and start a personalized conversation (chat or video) at the perfect moment.
Plug your leaky sales pipeline by engaging with your website visitors while you have their attention. Sign up for an account here.